Is it better to repair or replace a transmission?
Transmission Problems – Rebuild or Replace?
Some of the most dreaded words any car owner can hear are that their vehicle needs a new transmission. Replacing a transmission is quite possibly one of the most expensive services that your car will ever require because working with the transmission is incredibly complex and can be quite time-consuming too. In most circumstances, you have two choices when you replace the transmission on a vehicle. You can rebuild the transmission or install a new (replacement) transmission. So, which of these is the best option? The answer isn’t always cut and dry.
Rebuilding a transmission means that your existing transmission will be taken completely apart and inspected. Any damaged parts are replaced until the transmission is back to factory specs. In most cases, the gaskets and other rubber parts will all be replaced, but damaged moving parts may need to be replaced as well. This is a complex process and rebuilding a transmission is a job for a specialist for certain.
The beauty of rebuilding a transmission is that you can rebuild an older transmission with up-to-date parts that manufacturers have designed to be more efficient and safe. While a transmission rebuild is a great solution in many cases, it can be challenging to find a transmission specialist who is up to the task and it may take him or her some time to complete the job correctly.
Installing A Replacement Transmission
Replacing your transmission is a bit misleading–in most cases, you can’t actually find a “new” transmission. You’re likely working with a remanufactured transmission. This is similar to a rebuilt transmission, but it was done in a factory setting. For a quick fix, this is ideal. However, you may not have access to the most up-to-date parts and you don’t get to pick and choose how it is rebuilt.
Work with a Transmission Expert
Deciding on whether your transmission should be rebuilt or replaced is usually a question of cost and time to complete the repair. Having a transmission expert rebuild your transmission may take a little longer and cost a bit more upfront, but it can result in a longer-lasting and better-performing transmission. The other option of installing a “new to you” transmission still assures you have a safe, functional vehicle but you may not get as many options. Whichever way you are leaning, it makes sense to discuss your desires with an expert.
Things to consider before replacing or repairing
There are a few things to consider when deciding whether to replace or repair your transmission or perhaps even scrap or sell the car. Here are some things you should consider.
If you spend many hours in the garage to replace transmission parts, then it is time to replace them. Long-term repairs are expensive, especially if the problem keeps recurring. Frequent failures are not uncommon with gearboxes that have traveled more than 100,000 miles. If you find that your car spends many hours in the garage instead of on the road, it’s time to replace it.
Most transmission problems can be solved. A repair will cost you several hundred dollars, but if the total cost of the repair exceeds the cost of a new transmission, it’s time to buy a new transmission.
Fixing transmission problems
It can be a Herculean task for car owners to know what is wrong with the car’s transmission and you will need to ask your mechanic for help. There are some gearbox repairs that are easy to fix, while others are so expensive that a new transmission is required.
Delayed shifting response
The transmission helps to change the gear system. If you are driving your car and suddenly the gears are delayed, you have a problem with the transmission. If you drive a manual car, you will have difficulty shifting the car into the correct gear. With automatic cars, there is a delay in engaging the gear when the car is parked in the car park.
You will notice that the car does not move because the engine is roaring and there is some kind of delay. This is often a worn clutch that can be easily changed. You should rev up the car when changing gears and pay attention to a delayed shift reaction.
Clunking or humming sound
First, there are many engine components that can produce this rattling noise. You must eliminate these before you commit yourself to the transmission. It could be that your drive axle bearings or brake pads are worn out. A well-running transmission is often quiet, but the rattling noise is more pronounced in vehicles with manual transmission than in automatic vehicles.
As soon as you hear this humming, have the car checked by a mechanic. Further use of the car will cause more damage.
Diagnostics Are Everything
Once you have come to the conclusion that it’s actually the transmission that needs to be fixed, this can lead to an entirely new set of conclusions that may be drawn. Many of us make the mistake of bringing our vehicle to any transmission repair shop that may do it quickly or at a reasonable price. However, you need a reputable mechanic shop that knows how to correctly Vehicle Courtesy Check what has failed.
Even though a transmission repair can cost a lot, it is worth doing it right the first time with someone you can trust. A repair shop that knows how to correctly diagnose what the problem really is and how to fix it the right way is ideal. There are actually three different options when it comes to getting your transmission back to a good working condition-make sure that the right option is chosen for your particular issue.
Automatic or manual – what’s the difference?
In most cases, we tend to think a car has either a manual or automatic transmission. There are varying levels of automatic transmission, but for this article, we’ll assume only the two.
Manual transmissions use a stick shift to change gear ratios manually. If you’ve ever driven a manual, you know how to “feel” the process. As the engine revs, you push the clutch in to separate the gears. You use the shift to move between several different positions, then engage by pulling back on the clutch. You can hear the engine power reach capacity before engaging the process all over again.
Automatic transmissions do the same thing through the use of fluid pressure. An automatic transmission uses transmission fluid to provide the necessary pressure to activate the clutch and determine which gear the car should be in. It finds the right gear ratio and places the gear in motion.
When is Transmission Replacement Better Than Repair?
Transmission replacement – transmission repair guyYou should consider replacement when your current transmission is giving you a lot of problems, it is on the verge of failure, it would take too long to diagnose and fix, or the cost to repair is higher than what it costs to replace. Here’s why:
Lots of problems – If your current transmission is giving you a lot of problems, it could indicate that there are more problems to come. This means you will have to bring your car in for repairs multiple times, which will add up over time. In the long run you might be paying a lot more just to repair it when you can replace it and not have to worry about future problems.
On the verge of failure – If your transmission is on the verge of failure, transmission replacement would be a good idea. A transmission that hasn’t been well cared for will have a shorter lifespan, so if it needs repair but has 100,000 miles and up, that should be a sign to replace. If you choose to repair it now, it might fail soon afterwards and you’ll end up replacing it anyways.
Too long to diagnose and fix – Sometimes transmissions will develop problems that take too long to diagnose, and the longer your car stays in the shop, the more you’ll have to pay in the end. If the repair shop is having a hard time finding what the problem is, you might want to consider replacing your transmission unless you want the charges to stack up.
High transmission repair cost – Transmission repair won’t always be expensive, but this depends on how big the problem is. Costs can run anywhere from $1500 for minor repairs to $4000 for a complete rebuild. If the problem is minor you should opt for repair, but if repairs cost more than transmission replacement you should consider the latter as you’ll be saving money as well as getting a quality transmission out of it.